Maple Old Fashioned

Cara Campbell
by Cara Campbell
1 person
7 min

Welcome, friends to one of my favourite drinks: the maple old fashioned. This cocktail is booze forward, but balanced out by the maple flavour, hit with some citrus and cherry for an amazing nuanced drinking experience. While I think you can totally drink this any time of year (what can I say, I'm Canadian, and maple syrup season is 12 months a year), it definitely goes best with a cozy fire, an thick pair of socks and a well-worn novel.

What Goes in a Maple Old Fashioned?

One of the best parts about this cocktail is how few ingredients it takes, and how easy it is to make. It consists of:

  • Whiskey or bourbon
  • Maple syrup
  • Orange bitters
  • Cherry (for garnish)
  • Fresh or dehydrated orange peel (for garnish)

And that's it. If you can't find orange bitters (obsessed with these orange and juniper bitters from Bittered Sling, btw), you can definitely swap them out for something else, think cherry, cinnamon or some other warming winter spice. Don't skip out on them entirely though, they're pretty necessary to balance out the overt sweetness of the maple syrup.

Also, I feel like this should not need to be said, but please, for the love of god, use real maple syrup in this recipe.

Flavour Notes

The flavours you pick up will vary depending on the whiskey or bourbon you use. Again, a whiskey with notes of winter spices, like cinnamon, clove, and allspice work well with this recipe. Of course, maple will be one of the predominant flavours. Orange you can pick up from the bitters, but also the aroma of the fresh peel we're going to rub around the rim of the class. Finally, a brandied cherry adds a depth of flavour to the cocktail - making it a winter classic, and with some similarities to the Amaretto Sour.

The Smoked Maple Old Fashioned

This is an incredibly popular cocktail to try smoking with, because all of the flavour notes already go so well with that smoky aroma you get. Plus, this will honestly transport you to a mountain cabin beside a roaring wood-burning fire while fat snowflakes fall softly outside the window (aka my version of heaven). If you have a smoking gun, I highly encourage you to give it a try! If you don't have one, getting one will up your home-bartending game by approximately 1000% because it's so much fun.

Can't you just smell it from here?! So cozy.

The Best Whiskey to Use

In a typical old fashioned, we'd be looking for a Goldilocks whiskey or bourbon: not too sweet, not too spicy, something smooth that slides into the "just right" category. With a maple old fashioned, we have to consider whiskeys that pair well and will hold up to the rich and sweet maple syrup. Here's a few suggestions:

  • Suntory Whisky Toki: If you haven't had a Japanese whiskey yet, you're missing out, and this is a great one to start with. It pair particularly well in a maple old fashioned because of the citrus notes combined with some bitter herbs that will hold their own with the maple syrup.
  • Rittenhouse Straight Rye: this is a favourite of bartenders because it plays well in most cocktails, due to it's complex spice notes (again, ideal with maple syrup). It's also widely available and super affordable.
  • Tenjaku Blended Japanese Whisky: This one comes with a mild smoky flavour if you're looking for that smoked maple old fashioned feel, but don't want to spring (or don't have a smoking gun).
Recipe details
  • 1  person
  • Prep time: 7 Minutes Cook time: 0 Minutes Total time: 7 min
Show Nutrition Info
Hide Nutrition Info

  • 1 1/2 oz whiskey or bourbon
  • 3/4-1 oz maple syrup
  • 1 dashes orange bitters *One dash is equal to ten drops - so approximately ten shakes of your bitters
  • 1 chunk fresh orang peel
  • 1 brandied cherry

Combine you whiskey, maple syrup, and orange bitters in a cocktail mixer half filled with ice. Stir for 30-45 seconds.
Pour into a rocks glass with a large ice cube (ice cube is optional, the drink should be cold after you stir it with the ice).
Take the outside of the orange peel, and rub it around the rim of the glass. Use the peel as a garnish in the drink if you like more orange flavour.
Garnish with a brandied cherry on a cocktail pick, or a dehydrated orange slice.
  • If you want to smoke this cocktail, by all means go for it. If you're making more than one cocktail, I would suggest mixing the whiskey, maple syrup and bitters in the cocktail mixer without ice, and then capturing the smoke in the mixer with plastic wrap, or some heavy piece of wood, like a cutting board.
  • For individual drinks, again, capture the smoke in the glass with a heavy lid, getting as tight of a seal as you can. If you're adding ice, do this at the end.
Cara Campbell
Want more details about this and other recipes? Check out more here!